Google Photos is an impressive service; however, in line with Google’s nature, there’s a slightly eerie aspect to how remarkably proficient it is at specific tasks. For instance, you might have observed location details attached to your photos, even when you’ve deactivated location services in both the app and the camera. What’s the explanation for this?
Consider this scenario: You’ve explicitly denied location access for both the Google Photos app and your phone’s camera app. Despite this, you still find location information being displayed within Google Photos. This perplexing situation is both vexing and puzzling. How is Google able to retrieve this information if you’ve turned off location data for the camera?
Google Photos at a Glance
Google Photos is a widely-used service that allows users to store, manage, and share their photos and videos. One of the standout features of the platform is its ability to organize photos based on various criteria, including location. When you first use Google Photos, the app often prompts you to allow access to your device’s location. But what happens if you decline or turn off the location services?
Location Services: How They Work?
Generally speaking, smartphones determine your location through GPS, Wi-Fi, and cellular networks. Google’s ecosystem—comprising Android and various Google apps—often uses this information for features like location-based reminders or maps. When you turn off location services, your device stops using GPS to determine your location, but that doesn’t mean all location data ceases to exist.
Read More: Google Released New Privacy Tools
How Google Photos Uses Location Information?
The inclusion of location information in your photos is called geotagging. Geotagged photos make it easy for users to search and organize their photos based on where they were taken. This could be useful, for instance, when you want to pull up all the photos from your last vacation. The location data also aids Google Photos’ AI algorithms in creating event-based albums and offering other personalized features.
The Problem Isn’t the Photos
Naturally, one might jump to the conclusion that Google Photos is sourcing location information directly from the photos themselves. This is the conventional method—photos come with location details stored in the EXIF metadata, which the app can access.
However, the act of deactivating location access in your phone’s camera app doesn’t only prevent the camera from embedding location data from the device’s GPS module into the photo’s metadata. You can easily verify the EXIF data of any photo on various platforms. Interestingly, even when dealing with a photo lacking any EXIF data, Google Photos might still manage to associate a location with it. Despite your potential discomfort with this seemingly persistent connection of location data to the photo, it’s worth acknowledging Google’s shrewd approach to achieving this.
Google Can “Guess” Where You Are
Google doesn’t necessarily rely on highly accurate GPS location data to determine the origin of a photo. A prime illustration of Google’s recognition capabilities can be found in Google Lens. If you use the Google Lens app to scan a landmark, it’s highly probable that the app will accurately identify it. Google employs a similar methodology to assign “Estimated Locations” to photos.
The other crucial component here is your Location History. If you’ve activated this feature, Google essentially maintains a continuous record of your whereabouts. Consequently, even if both the Google Photos app and your camera are restricted from accessing your location, Google can still obtain this information from other applications, especially on Android devices. The process of deducing where a photo was taken becomes rather straightforward for Google if it’s aware of your location at the time the photo was captured.
Fortuitously, the utilization of Location History for photos was an opt-in feature that Google eliminated last year. The likely source behind the “Estimated Location” attribution, which employs recognizable landmarks to determine your location, can be identified. The positive aspect is that you have the ability to deactivate this feature if you wish.
How to Turn Off Estimated Location in Google Photos
To disable Google Photos’ “Estimate Missing Locations” function, you can conveniently navigate to the following locations: On Android, go to Settings > Privacy > Location Options; on iPhone and the desktop website, access Settings > Location. Once you’ve made this adjustment, you might encounter a prompt to eliminate any existing estimated locations that were appended to your photos.
It’s evident that Google possesses extensive knowledge about individuals, with location data being among the more unsettling aspects. Fortunately, Google provides several avenues to control your location history, including the option to automatically delete it after a specified period of time. This level of control empowers users to manage their privacy more effectively.
Read More: Google Pixelbook 12in
Alternative Methods of Determining Location
When GPS is off, your device can still use cellular tower triangulation and Wi-Fi positioning to determine your location. These methods are not as accurate as GPS but can still provide a reasonable estimate of where you are.
Device Sensor Data
Modern smartphones come equipped with a variety of sensors like inertial measurement units (IMU) and barometric pressure sensors that can offer clues about your location or movement, albeit in a less direct manner.
Metadata from Photos and Videos
If you’ve used a different camera to take a photo and then uploaded it to Google Photos, that image might already contain EXIF data, including location information. Google Photos can read this embedded information.
Social and Behavioral Clues
Google might also use non-location-based data, like time zone settings, language preferences, and search behaviours, to make educated guesses about your location.
Google’s Policies and Statements
According to Google’s privacy policies, they are committed to being transparent about how they collect and use location data. Google Photos adheres to these policies, and any changes to these are usually announced via updates or blog posts.
User Control and Settings
Fortunately, users have control over their location settings. You can manage or disable location permissions for Google Photos from your device settings. It is also possible to remove location data from previously uploaded photos within the Google Photos app.
Implications for Privacy
While location tagging can be incredibly useful, it does raise some concerns about user privacy. Companies like Google are under ethical obligations to handle this sensitive data carefully. Users should also take the initiative to educate themselves and make use of available privacy settings to control how their data is used.
While turning off location services may limit GPS-based tracking, Google Photos can still determine your location through a variety of other means, including network information and sensor data. The balance between convenience and privacy is delicate, and it’s up to individual users to decide where that balance lies for them.